Tuesday, 24 January 2017

Jameson Caskmates Review [My worst Score]

Hi everyone,

It is with great regret and pleasure that I give you my lowest scoring whisky so far. It’s Jameson Caskmates, as if the normal stuff wasn’t good enough, they finished it in Stout casks from a local brewery. Unfortunately, I’m not a big fan of beer and Stout is way into territory I don’t care to tread.

Normal Jameson first, for reference:

Jameson 40%
Colour: E150a
Body: Light
Nose: Cut grass, jam and marmalade, floral and herbal, flowers and pollen, vanilla, bit of fudge.
Taste: Light and thin. Vanilla, sweet light fruit, tangy into the finish.
Finish: Short length. Herbal.
A thin whisky that doesn’t do much for me.
48/100

Jameson Caskmates 40%
Colour: E150a
Body: Light
Nose: An earthy dark beer, marmalade, jam, lime, toast, butter. With time- Nail polish, more floral Irish notes- Grass, sweet oak, more Stout and steak. An awful combination.
Taste: Very creamy arrival, then nothing for a second, then developing dark beer, toast, marmalade, some oak, some salt and grass. Weird flavours, thin again.
Finish: Medium length. Bitter cheap coffee and tannins, unfortunate. Shudders
Partially matured in Ex-Stout casks. I hate beer, esp. Stout. Probably explains why I really don’t like this. I’m sure there are worse whiskies out there, but for the moment this is my lowest score I’ve given a whisky.
44/100

Thanks for reading!

Reviews #303-304

Network Average: 74.7
Best Score: 92
Worst Score: 44
0-49 Terrible
50-59 Bad
60-64 Just about OK
65-69 Ok to Good
70-74 Good
75-79 Very Good
80-84 Excellent
85-89 Superb
90+ Magnificent

Monday, 23 January 2017

Ledaig 1998 Cooper's Choice Sherry Cask Review

Hello again,

Another great Sherried peaty whisky to make you salivate today. It’s heavily peated whisky from Tobermory distillery, which makes it Ledaig.

Ledaig has been building a solid fan base recently I’ve noticed, mostly because I’ve become a part of it. It’s seriously grea…. Um, terrible. Just awful whisky. You should stay away from it really. It’s rubbery, meaty, gritty and there’s often a note of horse shit. Nope, you won’t like it.

Ledaig 1998 Cooper's Choice 56.5%
Colour: Dark Amber
Body: Full
Nose: Really wonderful mix of sweet Sherry and dirty smoke. A clean sweetness, earthy malt, coal, inner tube rubber, a biscuity shortbread note, oily, jelly baby, slightly meaty, venison?, black pepper, charred steak, some sulphurous smoke, almost volcanic? Juicy fig, pomegranate and grapefruit bring a freshness into the mix, cola bottle sweets.
Water: Notes meld together and balance well. Less overt smoke and earthy/dirty notes, more discrete oak with freshly sawn oak and sandalwood. More of the farmy notes with stables, manure and hay. Orange chewing gum.
Taste: Clean arrival with lots of cherry, black cherry, cola bottle sweets, very intense development, mineral stoniness, dark raisin and fig, oily Sherry, earthy smoke, dirty, soiled hay?, sulphurous smoke, smoky malt, lots of black pepper building, the unami notes are back with a charred steak note into the finish.
Water: Softer, builds beautifully. Sweetness starts with the Sherry, spicy oak, white pepper, overt peat, smoky malt, sulphurous smoke, orange citrus and a big black liquorice note. Black pepper leads into the finish.
Finish: Long length. Very oily, ashy, earthy, some Sherry sweetness. Better with water, with a savoury smoke and lovely sweetness. Liquorice again.
Masterful. A huge dirty whisky with character for days.
88/100

At £90, maybe I should have bought 2 bottles and saved you from having to taste this disgusting stuff.

This bottling is actually a great example of ‘good’ Sulphur in a whisky, which I was talking about the other day. Really pulls it off.

Thanks for reading!

Review #302

Network Average: 74.9
Best Score: 92
Worst Score: 44
0-49 Terrible
50-59 Bad
60-64 Just about OK
65-69 Ok to Good
70-74 Good
75-79 Very Good
80-84 Excellent
85-89 Superb
90+ Magnificent

Sunday, 22 January 2017

Laphroaig 1998 Signatory Sherry for TWE Review

Hi everyone,

I've got a very special one today from Laphroaig. This was bottled independently by Signatory vintage but was selected and bottled for The Whisky Exchange.

After being distilled on Islay in 1998, from what I can only assume was barley steeped in Unicorn tears, it was filled into a refill Sherry butt that must have previously held 1970's Clynelish and was made from oak air dried for many years by someone gently blowing air on it 24 hours a day, only taking small breaks to rest.
I would assume this because something special happened in that barrel over 15 years.

Laphroaig 1998 Signatory Cask Strength TWE 60.8%
Colour: Light Amber
Body: Full(!)
Nose: A huge sherried peat monster. Big Sherry sweetness excellently balanced by the Lahroaig peat and medicinal notes. Thick and oily, syrup, raisin, loads of TCP, bandages, sticking plasters, cough sweets, Calpol. There is some peat and smoke but a more medicinal brute. Despite itself there's still some lovely juicy citrus maintaining a freshness and balancing it out- Lime and orange.
After a bit- Engine oil, sea spray, fresh sea air, iodine, some liquorice and orange chewing gum.
Water: Orange! More earthy too, a little iodine, juicy citrus with some lemon too, the medicinal notes have receded.
After time- Wet leaves, forest floor, resinous sweetness, then more complex sweet sherry with excellently balanced citrus and peat.
Taste: Very, very powerful. Amazing arrival on waves of thick sweetness- Raisin and sherry, orange, overwhelmingly awesome, developing long amazing smoke- Peat, kiln, flint, and medicinal sweetness on TCP and bandages then sticking plasters and sweet orange. There's a minerality all through it too. Incredible development.
Water: More sweet, lots of intense orange, sweet lemon and lime. Big beautiful peat kicking up again, kiln and flint then some ginger and white pepper developing. Perfect balance and long development. Very juicy and sweet and going a little sour into the finish. B.E.A.uoooootiful...
Finish: Long length. Fades easily on sweetness but a peaty note stays and stays with an orange undercurrent.
Water: More orange and sour lime, less peat.
Savagely beautiful. Expert balance of flavours. Power, complexity, everything you could want from Sherried Laph at this age.
90/100

A magnificent Laphroaig that really sings!
Well done to all involved in making this wonderful whisky.

Thanks for reading!

Review #301

Network Average: 74.8
Best Score: 92
Worst Score: 44
0-49 Terrible
50-59 Bad
60-64 Just about OK
65-69 Ok to Good
70-74 Good
75-79 Very Good
80-84 Excellent
85-89 Superb
90+ Magnificent

Saturday, 21 January 2017

Jura Reviews: 10 Origin, 12 Elixir, 16 Duirach's, Superstition & Prophecy

Hi everyone,

Got another multi-review dump today. It’s Jura. No, we’re not going to dump on Jura… Ok, maybe a little, but it hasn’t really got the best reputation. Maybe for good reason.

Anyway, it’s the only distillery on the Isle of Jura, just over the way from Islay. But unlike most Islay drams, they mostly make unpeated whisky. A smaller portion of peated whisky is made under other labels. Both are reviewed here.

Jura 10 Origin 40%
Colour: E150a
Body: Light
Nose: Bit of salt, yeasty, flour, bread, butter, caramel, bit of floral, some honey, cereal, fruity note- Apple.
Taste: Light and sweet, oily, brine, salt, honey, faint spice, coffee, butter, heather bit of pepper, very mild citrus fruit.
Finish: Short length. Disappears with faint hints of oak.
Not the best, but quite cheap on deal.
61/100

Jura 12 Elixir 40%
Colour: E150a
Body: Medium
Nose: Lots of caramel, nuts, spice, fruity- Plums?
Taste: Caramel, toffee, fudge, more chewy caramel, bit of spice, tiny bit of smoke.
Finish: Short length. Oaky spice.
Very simple, a one note whisky really. Just overwhelming caramel.
65/100

Jura 16 Duirach's Own 40%
Colour: E150a
Body: Medium
Nose: Sweet and relaxed. Baking bread, yeast, raisins, apricot, rising dough, pastry, strudel, brioche, sherry, cinnamon and nutmeg. Burnt pastry.
Taste: Sweet start, sherry raisin, apricot bread, cinnamon, nutmeg, liquorice and some hay. A tiny bit of beach bonfire in the background. Bit of rough spice.
Finish: Short/Medium length. Sweet and syrupy ending with sherry and raisins.
A little bit better, but not really a fan of the burnt pastry style.
68/100
 
Jura Superstition 43%
Colour: E150a
Body: Medium
Nose: Lots of spice, tonnes of cinnamon, nutmeg, pepper, touch of smoke. Some sweetness with a cakey vanilla.
Taste: Fruity with lots of spicy cinnamon and some fruit and vanilla.
Finish: Short/Medium length. Spice with some smoke and salt.
Lightly peated, NAS. This is better, I like the cinnamon note on this.
70/100

Jura Prophecy 46%
Colour: E150a
Body: Medium/Full
Nose: Classic Jura, bready and malty, sour dough, sea spray, green oak, cinnamon, a little fresh ginger, Island-eque peat smoke, some lemon.
Water: More smoke and gingerbread. Seaweed and sea salt bread dough?
Taste: Sharp, some sour lemon and a little lime, then sea spray and Talisker-esque smoke, quite spicy with cinnamon and lots of spicy ginger, then more smoke into the finish.
Water: Softer arrival, a little medicinal note, bandages.
Finish: Medium length. Salty smoke then a baking note.
Islay peat smoked (Port Ellen) to 40ppm. Tasted blind I might have guessed Talisker.
73/100

Thanks for reading!

Reviews #296-#300!! Yay!

Network Average: 74.8
Best Score: 92
Worst Score: 44
0-49 Terrible
50-59 Bad
60-64 Just about OK
65-69 Ok to Good
70-74 Good
75-79 Very Good
80-84 Excellent
85-89 Superb
90+ Magnificent

Friday, 20 January 2017

Reviewing the Blends: VAT 69, Clan Campbell, Chivas 12, JW Black 12, Dewars 12, Kenmore 5, Famous Grouse & Whyte & Mackay

Hello, hello everyone!

Well, well, well. Something different for today. It’s the blends. The cheap, mass produced stuff. Yep, there it is, on the bottom shelf, right below all the single malts. Might be why we look down on them.
On the plus side, they are cheap. They are available throughout the world and there doesn’t tend to be much marketing or unnecessary packaging because it would drive the price up.

If you didn’t know, a blended Scotch whisky is a blend of grain whisky (normally around 70%) and malt whisky.
Grain whisky is normally made using wheat, or maize with some malted barley with huge column stills. Whereas malt whisky is made using only malted barley from pot stills.
Grain whisky is usually much lighter and I normally find a young lemon-y note. Malt whisky is normally much more full flavoured and has more character.

Now, I haven’t really tasted many blends because I am a malt snob. There, I said it. I seek out Scotch single malt above all others because it’s what I enjoy. That said, for the money, they can be expensive and it’s rare you get a good bargain these days. Marketing, NAS and price hikes.
Maybe there’s an honesty about blends. Everyone knows that they’ll be 3 years old, everyone knows they’re coloured. No one really cares that much, because it’s what people are looking for in a blend.

So, I’ve got a few basic ones for your reading pleasure now, but warning, some low scores are inevitable.
 
VAT 69 40%
Colour: E150a
Body: Light
Nose: Very very grainy, some light lemon and sour green apple.
Taste: Again, very grainy, almost a grainy/gritty mouthfeel as well (In a bad way). Zesty with lemon and green unripe apple.
Finish: Short length. Grainy gritty lemon.
Diageo export blend. Very young, 90% or more grain I think.
45/100

Clan Campbell 40%
Colour: E150a
Body: Light
Nose: Light, fruity and grainy. Very light fruit- Apple and pear. Quite Aberlour.
Taste: Grainy, sharp, then more smooth with apple and pear and building sour lemon.
Finish: Short length. Grainy spirit and lemon, very little vanilla.
Pernod Ricard export blend. Think there's some young Aberlour in there.
48/100

God, these export blends are awful. Let’s try some home turf.
 
Chivas Regal 12 40%
Colour: E150a
Body: Light
Nose: Lots of honey, fruit, bit of spice, sugar.
Taste: Sweet and light. Fresh fruit, apple, bit of honey, barley malt, grain, herbal note- Cloves and tea leaves. Some salt.
Finish: Short length. Salt and oak.
Another Pernod blend, but more malt I think. The age helps.
54/100

Johnnie Walker Black Label 12 40%
Colour: E150a
Body: Medium
Nose: Marzipan, toffee, almonds. Different every time- Sometimes waxy, salty, smoky or very sweet. Talisker and Coal Ila very recognisable.
Taste: Hint of smoke, vanilla and Sherry. Fruity, some spice. Caol Ila creamy smoke, lemon sherbet, grassy smoke.
Finish: Medium length. Smoke, bit of spice, vanilla and toffee.
Very malt driven with the smoke. I like this for a blend, a classic.
65/100

Dewars 12 40%
Colour: E150a
Body: Medium
Nose: Aberfeldy-esque, honey, nuts, spice, some sherry.
Taste: Honey, spice, heather, grain whisky developing with young lemon and a solvent note.
Finish: Medium length. Harsh grain alcohol and tannins.
An unfortunate one. Not every age statement is a good one.
51/100

Kenmore 5 40%
Colour: E150a
Body: Light
Nose: Sherried, malt, grain, toast, butter, lemon, a little oil and earth.
Taste: Creamy and thin, not much development, sweet sherried malt, toast, then lemon-y grain. A little grain alcohol into the finish.
Finish: Medium length. Sour lemon-y grain.
A Burn-Stewart one from M&S. Bunnahabhain, Deanston and Tobermory probably making up the malt component. Mentions ‘lightly peated’ on the bottle.
55/100

The Famous Grouse 40%
Colour: E150a
Body: Light/Medium
Nose: Sweet, great balance of malt and grain, heather, honey, toffee, some sherry. Highland Park does spring to mind.
Taste: Thin arrival, heather honey building with light smoke and sweet sherry. Lemon-y grain into the finish.
Finish: Medium length. Lemon grain and some heathery spice.
Not bad, not bad at all. Surprised by this one. Edrington group blend, owners of HP and Macallan, although I doubt there’s much in here.
62/100

Whyte & Mackay 40%
Colour: E150a
Body: Medium
Nose: Sherry sweetness, raisin and coffee, cherry, doughy Jura with some soft smoke. A little floral- Tamnavulin? Lemony grain underneath but quite malt forward.
Taste: Sweet and sherried, stewed fruit and raisin, cherry, mint, again the lemony grain is behind it. A little building harsh alcohol.
Finish: Short length. More grainy with lemon.
It's ok! Marriage in Sherry casks might not be bullshit. Really, a big surprise for me as I really wanted to dislike this.
64/100

Well, maybe that’s enough for now. Thanks for reading, if you managed it!

Reviews #288-#295

Network Average: 74.9
Best Score: 92
Worst Score: 44
0-49 Terrible
50-59 Bad
60-64 Just about OK
65-69 Ok to Good
70-74 Good
75-79 Very Good
80-84 Excellent
85-89 Superb
90+ Magnificent

Thursday, 19 January 2017

TBWC Islay Blended Malt #1 23yo Review

Hello everyone,

Got an interesting story and whisky today. It’s from That Boutique-y Whisky Co., it’s a blended malt all from Islay, it’s 23 years old and the components and percentages have been listed. A great move from them I think, really helping transparency and the reason I pre-ordered a bottle on their site when I saw it. Also, the price was right. About £80 for a 50cl bottle.

However, at the time of pre-ordering it was a different whisky. It was at 50.7% and there were 419 bottles.

The cheeky buggers then go and add some water to bring it down to 46.3% with 500 bottles. Which I probably wouldn’t have minded if Master of Malt had told me, which they didn’t bother to. Luckily, I saw it on the website and emailed them and they sent me a voucher for my trouble.

I still find it disturbing that they would water it down after putting it up for pre-order, even if it was better at that strength, because the price stayed the same. Unless it was actually cask strength and they made a mistake, which I find very unlikely as the number of bottles went up.

Sneaky.

Anyway, the whisky: It’s 60% Ardbeg, 35% Laphroaig and 5% Bowmore all aged over 23 years.

TBWC Islay Blended Malt #1- 23yo 46.3%
Colour: Dark Gold
Body: Medium/Full
Nose: Rich Bourbon barrel notes, lots of honey, coconut, roasted nut, cask wax, beeswax, honeycomb, milk chocolate. The smoke is in the background with engine oil, Ardbegian smoky lime juice, some lemon and a little orange too, seashore notes with rotting kelp and seaweed.
More fruit after a bit- Citrus, lemon, orange and lime, liquorice root and mint.
Water: A lot more tropical fruit coming out, mango, pineapple, seaside fudge shop, toffee,
Taste: Sweet arrival, lovely honey, a little tropical fruit, very rich, very long development, building oak but the smoke overcomes it, oily lime, some lemon, bandages, plasters, mineral flint, seashore, kelp, seaweed, seashells.
Water: A much softer arrival, vanilla, toffee, caramel, very oily development with lime and Ardbeg peat smoke, lots of soot and ash.
Finish: Long length. Oily smoke covers the mouth, lime oil, orange oil, soot and some mineral flint.
Cheap for so much older Ardbeg and Laphroaig in it. That said, I’m not sure watering this down helped as the smoky notes have been dampened I think, although that could be the maturation. Seems like 1st Fill Bourbon barrels to me.
85/100

Apologies for the complaining, thanks for reading!

Review #287

Network Average: 75.4
Best Score: 92
Worst Score: 44
0-49 Terrible
50-59 Bad
60-64 Just about OK
65-69 Ok to Good
70-74 Good
75-79 Very Good
80-84 Excellent
85-89 Superb
90+ Magnificent

VLOG