Monday, 30 January 2017

A rant about low scores and why they are important.

(This article was written for Reddit's r/Scotch community and is just an opinion)

Hi everyone,

The other day a well-known whisky blogger called me out on Facebook, telling me that my very low score for Jameson Caskmates was unjustified, suggesting that I had scored it so low for ‘blog hits’ (whatever those are) and that if I don’t like a whisky, then I shouldn’t say anything.

Another famous whisky blogger liked the comment, suggesting he agreed.

When I said that I was just sharing my opinion, the commenter went as far as to suggest that it looked like I scored it low because of where I work (at another Distillery).

I decided not to reply back straight away, but actually think about what had been said and what I would say back.
I could have started a childish Facebook argument, perhaps pack my bags, never to blog again or just ignore it.
What I will do instead is to give some more low scores and explain why I think they are important.

Skip down for the rant

Photo courtesy of Master of Malt
Balmenach 2002 Provenance 46%
Colour: Pale pale straw
Body: Light/Medium
Nose: Young and pungent. Quite in your face, musky, moss, olive oil, green and a little earthy, verging on stale but there's some young esters keeping it at bay. Pear drops, green apple, some vanilla, some American oak.
Taste: Gentle arrival, smooth and fruity with apple and pear then spice kicks up with strong oak coming through, tannins, chocolate, green sappy oak, coffee.
Finish: Medium length. Unfortunate, green, sappy, tannins, cheap coffee, a little hot alcohol.
Bottled 2012 at 10 years old. Cask 9864.

Photo courtesy of Master of Malt
Strathisla 2005 Malt of the Earth 46%
Colour: Pale pale straw
Body: Light/Medium
Nose: Ultra clean, distillate style. Bubblegum, some young fruit- Green apple, lots of pear, pear drops. Sour building now, sour spirit, lemon, vodka, slightly stale with sweaty socks.
Taste: Sharp and sweet. Zingy with loads of lemon, lemon juice, lemon sherbet, a little spice developing then some chocolate. Again, slightly stale in development and finish.
Finish: Medium length. Young but with chocolate, spice and coffee.
Bottled 2014 at 9 years old.

Reviews #315-#316


Should we score whisky?
Well, I can’t give an answer for everyone but for me it works. As Serge of Whiskyfun says, I haven’t found a better way of showing (to myself) which cask of 2005 Ledaig I liked better, 900160 or 900159. For a long time, I didn’t score whisky. I wrestled with starting to score when I started posting here. In the end, Serge’s post here convinced me that it was a good idea. I then thought about it a lot and developed my system over a few months.
Some people use a 0-10 system, some A-E. Some people don’t score whisky at all. That’s fine.

Are low scores important?
If you are scoring, then yes. If you didn’t, none of your scores would mean anything! If you score everything 90/100 or even just between 90-99 then 90 is a low score for you. Just because I give stuff 40/100, doesn’t mean that it’s 40 for you. A 40 for me might be your 60 or 70 or whatever.
If you got a shite pair of headphones from Amazon that broke the first time you wore them, would you give them 1 star? Another part of low scores is trying to help people not to make the same mistake you did.

Does it matter that I work at another distillery?
Yes. Of course, it does. And it doesn’t matter if I say I’m going to be unbiased in my views or as truthful as the virgin Mary because how can you believe me. You don’t know me. It doesn’t matter if you are Jim Murray or John Doe though, everyone is biased. Some more than others of course. In the end, use your judgement and experience.
Am I rating Ledaig and Ardbeg highly to lure you into buying stuff from the distillery I work for? Am I rating Jameson and Tamnavulin low to put you off them, and instead buy stuff from the distillery I work for?

Should I keep my mouth shut?
Hell no! I’m not going to stop my passion because anyone tells me to. I love reviewing whisky, I love the nuances and flavours. I love being critical and if I don’t think something is up to scratch, I’m going to bloody well tell you about it.

If daveswhiskyreviews gives a low score, does it mean I won’t like it?
No. NO. Everyone’s tastes are different. I am only 1 person. I can only give one person’s opinion. That’s why I contribute to r/Scotch archive and, because alone I mean nothing. Together, we can build a picture of views from many people from different backgrounds and different tastes from all over the world and that means something.

Now if you excuse me, I’m going to sit back and watch my huge blog hits roll in and make me a tonne of money from all the advertising I run, then open some exclusive samples from all the companies that send me free stuff. Sláinte

I’ll leave you with this quote from Serge.
It’s just a way of summing up impressions and opinions. Scores are opinions, expressed in a numerical form. They have to be put in relation with the taster who came up with the scores (and his experience as well as his possible commercial links to the bottlers), otherwise they are worthless. MOST IMPORTANT: in my view a high score doesn't mean you should rush out and buy a bottle or a palette, it means that in my opinion, you too should maybe try the whisky in question, provided we have similar tastes. Always try to taste a whisky yourself before you buy - if you can. – Serge Valentin (Whiskyfun)

Update: What has come out of a few comments made on this article is that I will be putting a disclaimer on all my reviews, stating who I work for and being more open in general so that people can make their own opinions about my reviews and biases.


  1. Great Post Mr Cover. Everything in life is scored. Movies, books, music, food, cars, travel companies etc etc. Any sensible soul will read your blogs and if they have a similar outlook to you, will like the whiskeys that you like and vice versa. As you say, it is an opinion.

    How many times have you gone to see a movie with an actor you like thinking it would be rubbish because it only got 2 stars only to come out having enjoyed a great movie. Or the opposite!

    Keep up the great work. There is no compromise.

    Be yourself.



  2. Love it David.

    It is hard to give a low rating as it is hard to give a perfect 100 also. At the end of the day it is a personal rating system and it does not fit any other personal scale. Sort of an individual fingerprint.

    Enjoyed this blog post. Be true to your beliefs. Rock on!

  3. Nicely well-written article. It was an awesome article to read. Complete rich content and fully informative
    Purchase Georget t stage whiskey

  4. Quality articles is the important to attract the people to pay a visit the website, that?s what this web site is providing.
    Purchase Georget t stage whiskey

  5. Pretty good I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts. Any way I'll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon. Big thanks for the useful info.



  6. I think this is an informative post and it is very useful and knowledgeable. therefore, I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article.

    Halfway House


  7. Nice post. I was checking this blog and I am impressed! Extremely helpful information specially the last part I care for such info a lot. I was seeking this particular information for a very long time. Thank you and good luck.
    bank statement for visa


  8. The electronic signature online application presents a great opportunity.
    Modern businesses require a digital partner to boost their document management. DocSignPro is going to be your perfect partner when inserting digital signature online pdf documents...


  9. EMS as employee monitoring software is for those corporate businesses who want to track their employees’ daily activity progress and limit their usage of unnecessary websites, hardware, and software.

    The Employee Monitoring System (EMS) has the capacity to monitor employee daily log activities on their system. With this employee monitoring software, you can track employee location through their IP address as well.

    Get analytical data for a more productive and efficient team. EMS Software benefits businesses to automatically assess employee productivity, efficiency, attendance, computer, and software use.


  10. Smart Apple Insurance is one of the pioneers of Insurance companies in New York. Smart apple started to provide its service to customers in 2001. Our goal is to provide customers with the best affordable rates for their insurance services.

  11. Teacher Kids offers online classes that are based on Tajweed. Our Quran tutors can help you learn Quran online and improve your Quran recitation.

    Every Muslim has a responsibility to learn the Quran. It is also important for Muslim parents to teach their children Quran reading from an early age.


  12. Therefore, certain regulations have to be reputable for this research system.
    Click here Tellthebell

  13. Nicely well-written article. It was an awesome article to read. Complete rich content and fully informative
    The Hiltonian
    The Hiltonian
    The Hiltonian
    The Hiltonian
    The Hiltonian